Sooner or later an apprentice will ask for a pay rise, or you'll be weighing up whether to give one. Award progression handles part of an apprentice's pay automatically, but discretionary rises — above-award pay, bringing a wage increase forward, or rewarding a standout — are a judgement call. Getting those calls right keeps your best people and keeps your wage bill sensible.
This guide explains how experienced employers actually decide who gets a pay rise, and how to think about it fairly. It's aimed at employers, but it also helps you understand what a reasonable request looks like versus one you can knock back with a clear conscience. First, though, it pays to be clear about what's automatic and what's discretionary.
Know what's automatic before you decide anything
Apprentice wages are set by the relevant modern award, and they rise automatically as the apprentice progresses — usually by year of the apprenticeship and, in many trades, by competencies completed. Those increases aren't a "pay rise" you decide on; they're an entitlement you have to pay.
Before you get into discretionary territory, make sure you're paying the correct rate for their stage, plus any allowances and the superannuation guarantee. Check the Wage Calculator and the Fair Work Ombudsman at fairwork.gov.au. Getting the award basics wrong is a far bigger risk than a discretionary rise. See Apprentice wage increases: when and how they happen.
Reliability and attitude come first
When it comes to a discretionary rise, the first thing most employers weigh is whether this is a person they want to keep and reward. That starts with reliability and attitude — the apprentice who turns up every day, has a go, takes feedback and gets on with the crew.
A rise is partly a retention tool. You give it to the people you'd hate to lose. A talented apprentice who's flaky, moody or hard to teach is not someone you're rushing to pay more, no matter how good their hands are. Reliability and attitude are the foundation everything else sits on. See Reliability beats talent: why turning up matters.
Are they more valuable than they were?
The core question behind any discretionary rise is simple: has this apprentice become more valuable to the business? Signs that they have:
- They need less supervision than they used to
- They can be trusted with jobs and tools you wouldn't have handed them before
- They make the crew more productive rather than creating rework
- They've picked up tickets or skills that expand what they can legally do
- They take on responsibility without being asked
If an apprentice is clearly doing more, and doing it well, a rise is easier to justify — you're paying for the value they now bring, not just rewarding time served. If they've stalled, award progression is enough. See How employers decide who gets more responsibility.
How they ask matters
The way an apprentice raises a pay rise tells you something. A reasonable request is made privately, professionally, at a sensible time, and backed by what they've actually done — not delivered as a demand, an ultimatum, or a comparison to what their mate down the road supposedly earns.
An apprentice who asks well, at the right time, having genuinely earned it, deserves a real conversation. One who corners you on a busy morning demanding more "or else" has told you something about their judgement. Neither the timing nor the tone should decide it on its own, but both are fair to weigh. You can share How to ask for a pay rise as an apprentice so they get it right.
Consistency and fairness across the crew
Whatever you decide for one apprentice ripples across the whole crew. Trade sites talk, and word gets around about who's on what. If you give one apprentice a discretionary rise for reasons the others can't see, expect resentment and a queue at your office door.
So apply a consistent principle: reward value, reliability and responsibility, and be able to explain the reasoning if asked. You don't have to pay everyone the same, but you should be able to justify differences on merit. Fairness you can defend keeps the peace; favouritism you can't defend poisons the crew.
What the business can actually carry
A rise has to be sustainable. It's better to give a modest increase you can maintain than a big one you have to claw back when work goes quiet. Factor in the full cost — the extra super on top, and the flow-on to other crew who'll expect similar.
Also think ahead: this apprentice's award rate will keep rising as they progress anyway. Stacking a large discretionary rise on top of guaranteed progression can leave you overcommitted by the time they qualify. Model it out before you promise anything.
Alternatives to a straight pay rise
If an apprentice deserves recognition but a permanent rise doesn't stack up, you've got other levers:
- Pay for tickets or courses that make them more useful — see Which tickets actually get you hired
- A one-off bonus for a big effort, rather than a permanent commitment
- More responsibility and better work — often what they actually want
- A clear path — tell them exactly what earns a rise and when you'll review it
Sometimes an apprentice asking for more money really wants to feel valued and see a future. Recognition, real work and a clear plan can address that without blowing the budget.
Be straight with them
However you decide, be honest. If they've earned it, say why and give it. If they haven't yet, tell them plainly what you need to see and when you'll revisit it. A vague "we'll see" breeds resentment; a clear answer, even a no, keeps trust intact. And never let a discretionary decision push you below the correct award rate — that's not a choice, it's a legal minimum.
Looking to build a crew worth investing in? Browse apprentice candidates or create a free employer profile.
Key takeaways
- Award progression is automatic — sort the correct rate, allowances and super first
- Discretionary rises reward reliability and attitude above raw talent
- The core test is whether the apprentice has genuinely become more valuable
- How and when they ask is fair to weigh, though not decisive on its own
- Keep it consistent and defensible across the crew to avoid resentment
- Only promise what the business can carry, including super and flow-on costs
- Bonuses, paid tickets, better work and a clear plan are alternatives to a permanent rise